In Reply to Tomasz Witkowski: To Foster a Culture of Common Sense

Ciekawe rozwinięcie moich refleksji zawartych w artykule, który niedawno ukazał się w Merion West. Zapraszam do lektury i do dzielenia się opiniami na jego temat.

Paul Sturdee

“What is needed is a return to a culture of common sense and personal well-being, in which one is judged according to what kind of person one is and how one conducts one’s life.”

A recent Merion West article by psychologist Tomasz Witkowski serves as a useful segue for entering into wider discussions about personal well-being, particularly when it comes to down-to-earth, common-sense notions of what it means to be a well-adapted, fully-functioning person. Additionally, Witkowski’s piece sheds light on what might be the best approach for addressing the psychological problems experienced by certain individuals. Witkowski recounts how psychotherapy has mushroomed into over 600 different therapeutic approaches, and yet the results achieved are not significantly better than everyday, common-sense methods to restoring psychological well-being. However, as with almost all attempts to characterize and address human problems, context is important.

Witkowski cites the work of Vikram Patel, who has written a book on how to deliver psychotherapy. Where There Is No Psychiatrist is aimed at lay-persons who can offer support to others. The premise is that poor, under-supported people may suffer from psychological problems as much as those with the time and money to dwell constantly on their mental health. The nature and distribution of the psychological problems might be somewhat different between the two groups; people without leisure or money tend to think and act very differently from those who have either or both. Still, there can be no doubt that poor mental health is not confined to those who have access to mental health services (i.e. wealthier people). 

The barefoot doctor schemes introduced in the developing world more than half a century ago were very successful at delivering basic healthcare to those previously without any, and Patel’s (very successful) initiative looks very much like a kind of barefoot psychotherapy. It does not need any attendant infrastructure or organization. With none of the complications inherent in an expert/client relationship, the barefoot psychotherapist is delving into a kit-bag of possible solutions, while accepting that the recipient is ultimately the authority on which approach is acceptable and which works best. 

This might seem a world away from the kind of therapeutic relationship we are accustomed to in the West, where theoretical orientation and technical skill are considered as important as the therapist’s personal qualities. This is why context is so important when assessing the cultural significance of psychotherapy and its allied pursuits of counseling and life-style coaching.

Having spent many years working in mental health settings before becoming an academic philosopher, and then many years studying the literature on theories of mental health and mental health treatments, I eventually came to the tentative conclusion that psychotherapy, in many cases, is an exercise in wishful thinking on the part of all concerned.

Czytaj dalej klikając TUTAJ

Posty o podobnej tematyce:

Bujany fotel z wachlarzem. Skąd wiemy, czy psychoterapia w ogóle działa?

Czy każdy potrzebuje terapeuty – pomoc czy przemysł?

O obrazie uczuć terapeutycznych

O słoniu, ślepcach i psychoterapii

Zasada primum non nocere w psychoterapii. Podejście oparte na nauce

Psychoterapia imitująca podejście oparte na dowodach. Cz. 1 Złoty standard

Psychoterapia imitująca podejście oparte na dowodach. Cz. 2 Przemilczenie

Psychoterapia imitująca podejście oparte na dowodach. Cz. 3 Konflikt interesów

Psychoterapia imitująca podejście oparte na dowodach. Cz. 4 Wizerunek bez cieni

Zapobieganie samobójstwom a nauka kultu cargo


Zawracanie statków głupców i inne eseje – okładka

Szerzej o tym, jak ideologia wypiera naukę, debatę i zdrowy rozsądek, piszę w zbiorze esejów „Zawracanie statków głupców i inne eseje”. Książka w księgarni Bonito »

Chcesz dostawać moje nowe teksty e-mailem? Zapisz się poniżej.

Skomentuj

Ta witryna wykorzystuje usługę Akismet aby zredukować ilość spamu. Dowiedz się w jaki sposób dane w twoich komentarzach są przetwarzane.